(Abby Martin is a Bay Area based citizen journalist and filmmaker - and sometimes Media Alliance volunteer).
Naomi Wolf's book, The End of America: Letter of Warning to a Young Patriot, argues that there are ten steps
common to every state that has made the transition into fascism. One
step is the targeting of key individuals or demographics: artists,
academics, activists, civil servants, gays, Jews; the public
blacklisting of those who don't tow the party line. Another move towards
fascism is the control over the press—all dictatorships and would-be
dictators target journalists and make sweeping media reforms to increase
their control and their ability to censor information.
Her book conveys the inklings of fascism here in America, but in a
globalized society, the West sets the tone for policy and culture that
influences the rest of the world. As Orwellian rhetoric becomes
commonplace-- wars are being waged to maintain "peace" and draconian
bills that curtail civil liberties are being litigated as
"patriotic"—countries worldwide have been enacting Wolf's ten steps,
some with more haste than others.
After decades of post-Soviet, post-Holocaust political and economic
strife, Hungary is starting to embody Orwell's dystopian portrayal.
This April, Fidesz, Hungary's center-right conservative party, won
2/3rds control over Parliament, putting the conservative party in power
for the first time since World War II. Moreover, Fidesz now controls
22 out of the 23 major cities in the country. This complete takeover by
one party is significant, because the Hungarian Constitution can be
effectively changed with a 2/3rds majority in Parliament, an advantage
now regularly enacted by the new party in power.
In the hundred days following the election, sweeping measures were
passed by the Parliament that curtail Hungarians' freedoms. The reforms include
an installation of a "media presidium", drastic legislation against
journalistic independence and an attempt to control the content coming
from the last remaining independent art centers and theatres. The
government is taking these actions under the new mantra of
"re-nationalization", an effort where judicial law is compromised and
the consolidation of power is increased under nationalist rhetoric.
This new mantra is conveyed in a government manifesto that is now
required by law to be displayed in every public sphere across the
country.
Another indication of Hungary's shift to the right is Jobbik, a right
wing nationalist party known for their anti-Semitic and anti-gay speech
that won an unprecedented 47 seats into Parliament. The growing
influence of prominent extreme right political players is in part a
backlash from the Socialist Party's failures which resulted in a
disenfranchised, fragmented left. In 2008, Hungary experienced an
economic collapse and was subsequently bailed out by the International
Monetary Fund. Amid their economic struggle, Hungarians became
disillusioned with Socialism, leading to the eventual takeover of the
center and far right. Presently, under Fidesz's reign, the public live
in an unpredictable political climate in which Jobbik's bigoted ideology
could gain momentum among alienated Hungarians that feel unrepresented
by the current government. Already, an anonymously published list of
many prominent Jewish, Bolshevik and Homosexual Hungarian political and
cultural figures has been circulated, bolstering a climate of
demonization that is reminiscent of McCarthy's Communist era
blacklisting. The targeting and slandering of different groups and
demographics of the population are essential tools for a would-be
dictatorship to propagate the fear required for a compliant culture.
In an attempt to eliminate society's free expression, the Cultural Committee of the government has recommended
the "removal of independent theatres and contemporary moving art
companies from the roll of accredited artistic organizations". Fidesz
has refused to disperse 1/3 of the money already allocated for the
independent theater and art sector, resulting in cancellations of major
festivals and closure of numerous art centers. A complete cessation of
government funds would not only threaten thousands of jobs but would
also significantly threaten Hungary's celebrated culture and heritage.
The art organizations that remain are receiving "content
recommendations" from government, requiring that the art reflect kindly
on the nation. This is particularly alarming given the crucial role of
independent art and media in times of political and societal despair. In
every country, such outlets have served an essential role in society by
reflecting a cultural climate and shaping people's greater
understanding of the world in which they live. Forums for dialogue and
independent expression naturally breed dissent against the status quo,
which likely explains the harsh crackdown on the art and media sector
since Hungary's abrupt political transition. Many are disagreeing with
the suppression—there have already been multiple high profile
resignations attributed to the government's intrusion in this field.
Fidesz's latest assault
on the arts is focused on the internationally acclaimed National
Theatre of Hungary and its award winning art director, Robert Alfoldi.
Members of Parliament have pronounced the Theatre "dangerous,
anti-national and anti-Hungarian" for its plans to host a Romanian
holiday concert, and are calling for the immediate resignation of
Alfoldi for his "betrayal". On December 1st, Jobbik held a rally outside
of the National Theatre building with the purpose of instigating
Alfoldi's expulsion. If Alfoldi is dismissed early from his term without
legal basis, his removal would signify a dangerous precedent in which
leaders from any cultural institution can be dismissed simply because of
the ruling party's ideals.
At the same time, an even more controversial piece of legislation passed
under Fidesz is the new "Media Constitution" or Bill T/363, which set
up the framework to regulate Hungary media on a day-to-day basis for the
next nine years or longer. According to Dr. Karol Jakubowicz,
an international expert in broadcasting and a member of the Kosovo
Independent Media Commission, Bill T/393 creates a registration system
that would construct potential legal and political barriers to new
content entering the media landscape in conjunction with providing
Hungary's government the ability to take increased action against
existing providers of "vaguely unwanted content".
Another aspect of the bill prohibits the incitation to hatred against
nations, ethnic, religious, minority or majority groups. According to
Jakubowicz, the vague restriction of "inciting hatred" is a slippery
slope that would undoubtedly lead to similar sanctions of unintentional
insult or inadvertent incitement to hatred from media outlets that are
simply capable of insult and exclusion.
Jakubowicz writes
that Bill T/363 "require[s] instituting a system of surveillance,
supervision and possible repression that are unacceptable in a
democratic society... placing Hungary alongside authoritarian countries
seeking to control all forms of social communication."
The moves by the Fidesz government to alter the constitution, as well as
to control modes of communication and social networks in the country,
amount to a current political setting that has unsettling similarities
to Germany's rise to fascism. Dictatorships and developing fascist
states have always expelled nationalist rhetoric and Party propaganda
justifying the takeover of free society—the Nazi Party in Germany
believed propaganda was a vital tool in achieving their goals, and
produced it under the Orwellian "Ministry of Public Enlightenment".
In the Nazi Party manifesto, the first point demanded the "union of all
Germans in a Great Germany on the basis of the principle of
self-determination of all peoples." Similar propaganda is emerging in
Hungary in the guise of the Fidesz Party's manifesto, The Hungarian National Assembly of National Cooperation,
which states that Hungary has "regained the right and power of
self-determination". Frighteningly, Fidesz's political declaration is
now mandated to be prominently displayed and framed in most public
spaces across the country.
The manifesto further declares
that a Hungarian revolution took place in April's elections in which
"Hungarians decided to create a new system: The National Cooperation
System. With this historical act the Hungarian nation obliged the
incoming National Assembly and Government to take the helm at this
endeavor, resolute, uncompromising and with deliberation, and control
the construction of the National Cooperation System in Hungary."
The document also explains that this "new social contract" will "bring
together the diverse Hungarian nation," creating a future based on the
societal pillars of "work, home, family, health and order." Hungary's
nationalist rhetoric is all too similar to the coded words ringing from
previous regimes that sought to homogenize the face and values of the
nations they ruled.
In Nazi Germany, journalists, writers, and actors were required to tow
the official Party line on world events, and had to get their work
pre-approved by the state before disseminating it to the public. In
Hungary, artists are receiving "content recommendations" from the
government, and the new Hungarian Media Constitution requires that all
media shall provide "appropriate information" that is "factual, timely
and balanced"--all factors that are determined by Fidesz.
Nazism and Communism still scar Hungary's past. The country's regression
to its dark history should be watched closely by the international
community, especially the European Union (EU). Hungary's 2004 membership
into the EU symbolized an agreement to operate under an ethical code of
political and societal conduct established by the EU's Charter of
Fundamental Rights. The Charter prohibits discrimination and enshrines
the freedom of expression, thought, and religion for all EU citizens.
Already, Fidesz has set up a legal framework restricting free
expression, and has created a climate of fear that impinges upon
Hungarians' fundamental rights protected by the EU Charter. If
international attention and criticism are not received in time, Hungary
could continue down an authoritarian road similar to the
Nazis—eventually condemning, incarcerating or even killing those who do
not uphold the principles of the Party.
Abby Martin is a freelance writer, citizen journalist, activist and artist living in Oakland, CA. You can find more of her writing at www.MediaRoots.org and view her artwork at www.AbbyMartin.org |