Emil Guillermo interviews the killer of Vincent Chin - 30 years after the young Asian man was beaten to death with a baseball bat.
*****
After 30 years, the killer of Asian American icon Vincent Chin
told me in an exclusive interview that the murder known as a hate crime,
wasn't about race, nor does he ever even remember hitting Chin with a
baseball bat. Incredible as that sounds, there is one thing Ronald Ebens is clear about. Ebens,
who was convicted of second degree murder but spent no time in prison
for the act, is sorry for the beating death of Vincent Chin on June 19,
1982, in Detroit--even though for many Asian Americans, he can't say
sorry enough. For years, Ebens has been allowed to live his life quietly as a free man. With
the arrival of the 30th anniversary this month--and after writing about
the case for years--I felt the need to hear Ebens express his sorrow
with my own ears, so that I could put the case behind me. So I called him up. And he talked to me. On the phone, Ebens, a retired auto worker, said killing Chin was "the only wrong thing I ever done in my life."
Though
he received probation and a fine, and never served any time for the
murder, Ebens says he's prayed many times for forgiveness over the
years. His contrition sounded genuine over the phone.
"It's
absolutely true, I'm sorry it happened and if there's any way to undo
it, I'd do it," said Ebens, 72. "Nobody feels good about somebody's life
being taken, okay? You just never get over it. . .Anybody who hurts
somebody else, if you're a human being, you're sorry, you know."
Ebens
said he'd take back that night if he could "a thousand times," and that
after all these years, he can't put the memory out of his mind. "Are
you kidding? It changed my whole life," said Ebens. "It's something you
never get rid of. When something like that happens, if you're any kind
of a person at all, you never get over it. Never."
Ebens' life
has indeed changed. As a consequence of the Chin murder, Ebens said he
lost his job, his family, and has scraped by from one low-wage job to
the next to make ends meet. Ultimately, he remarried and sought refuge
in Nevada, where he's been retired eight years, owns a home and lives
paycheck to paycheck on Social Security. His current living situation
makes recovery of any part of the millions of dollars awarded to Chin's
heirs in civil proceedings highly unlikely. The civil award, with interest, has grown to around $8 million.
"It was ridiculous then, it's ridiculous now," Ebens said with defiance.
His
life hasn't been easy the last 30 years. But at least, he's alive. He
watches a lot of TV, he said, like "America's Got Talent."
"They've got good judges," he said.
Sort
of like the judges he got in his case? Like Judge Charles Kaufman, the
Michigan judge who sentenced him to probation without notifying Chin's
attorneys, virtually assuring Ebens would never serve time for the
murder? Ebens didn't want to comment on that.
For all the
time he spends in front of the television, Ebens said he has never seen
either of the two documentaries that have been made on the case, and
said he made a mistake speaking to one of the filmmakers. Even for this
column, Ebens showed his reluctance to be interviewed.
But he
finally consented to let me use all his statements because I told him I
would be fair. I'm not interested in further demonizing Ronald Ebens. I
just wanted to hear how he deals with being the killer of Vincent Chin. For
three decades, the Chin case has been a driving force that has informed
the passion among activists for Asian American civil rights. Some still
feel there was no justice even after the long legal ordeal that
included: 1) the state murder prosecution, where Ebens and his stepson,
Michael Nitz, were allowed to plea bargain to second degree murder,
given 3 years' probation and fined $3,720; 2) the first federal
prosecution on civil rights charges that ended in a 25-year sentence for
Ebens; 3) the subsequent appeal by Ebens to the Sixth Circuit, which
was granted; 4) the second federal trial that was moved from Detroit to
Cincinnati and ended in Ebens' acquittal.
Add it all up, and it
seems a far cry from justice. One man dead. Perps go free. I thought
that maybe Ebens could help me understand how he got justice and not
Vincent Chin.
I asked him about his side of the story, which was a
key dispute in the court testimony about how it all started at the
Fancy Pants strip club.
"It should never have happened," said
Ebens. "[And] it had nothing to do with the auto industry or Asians or
anything else. Never did, never will. I could have cared less about
that. That's the biggest fallacy of the whole thing."
That night
at the club, after some harsh words were exchanged, Ebens said Chin
stood up and came around to the other side of the stage. "He
sucker-punched me and knocked me off my chair. That's how it started. I
didn't even know he was coming," Ebens said.
Chin's friends
testified that Ebens made racial remarks, mistaking Chin to be Japanese.
And then when Chin got into a shoving match, Ebens threw a chair at him
but struck Nitz instead.
But Ebens' version that there was no
racial animosity or epithets is actually supported by testimony from
Chin's friend, Jimmy Choi, who apologized to Ebens for Chin's behavior
that included Chin throwing a chair and injuring Nitz.
What about the baseball bat and how Ebens and Nitz followed Chin to a nearby McDonald's?
Ebens
said when all parties were asked to leave the strip club, they were out
in the street. It's undisputed that Chin egged Ebens to fight on.
"The
first thing he said to me is 'You want to fight some more?'" Ebens
recalled. "Five against two is not good odds," said Ebens, who declined
to fight.
Then later, when Chin and his friends left, Ebens'
stepson went to get a baseball bat from his car.(Ironically, it was a
Jackie Robinson model). Ebens said he took it away from Nitz because he
didn't want anyone taking it from him and using it on them.
But
then Ebens said his anger got the best of him and he drove with Nitz to
find Chin, finally spotting him at the nearby McDonald's.
"That's
how it went down," Ebens said. "If he hadn't sucker punched me in the
bar...nothing would have ever happened. They forced the issue. And from
there after the anger built up, that's where things went to hell."
Ebens calls it "the gospel truth."
But
he says he's cautious speaking now because he doesn't want to be seen
as shifting the blame. "I'm as much to blame," he sadly admitted. "I
should've been smart enough to just call it a day. After they started to
disperse, [it was time to] get in the car and go home."
At the
McDonald's where the blow that led to Chin's death actually occurred,
Ebens' memory is more selective. To this day, he even wonders about
hitting Chin with the bat. "I went over that a hundred, maybe 1,000
times in my mind the last 30 years. It doesn't make sense of any kind
that I would swing a bat at his head when my stepson is right behind
him. That makes no sense at all."
And then he quickly added, almost wistfully, "I don't know what happened." Another
time in the interview, he admitted his memory may be deficient. "That
was really a traumatic thing, " he told me about his testimony. "I
hardly remember even being on the stand."
He admitted that everyone had too much to drink that night. But he's not claiming innocence.
"No,"
Ebens said. "I took my shot in court. I pleaded guilty to what I did,
regardless of how it occurred or whatever. A kid died, OK. And I feel
bad about it. I still do."
Ebens told me he has Asian friends
where he lives, though he didn't indicate if he shares his past with
them. When he thinks about Chin, he said no images come to mind.
"It
just makes me sick to my stomach, that's all," he said, thinking about
all the lives that were wrecked, both Chin's and his own.
By the
end of our conversation, Ebens still wasn't sure he wanted me to tell
his story. "It will only alienate people," he said. "Why bother? I just
want to be left alone and live my life."
But I told him I
wouldn't judge. I would just listen, and use his words. I told him it
was important in the Asian American community's healing process to hear a
little more from him than a one line, "I'm sorry."
He ultimately
agreed. One line doesn't adequately explain another human being's
feelings and actions. I told him I would paint a fuller picture.
So
now that we've heard what Ebens has to say 30 years later. I don't know
from a phone conversation if he's telling me the truth. Nor do I know
if I'm ready to forgive him. But I heard from him. And now that I have, I
can deal with how the justice system failed Vincent Chin, and continue
to help in the fight that it never happens again.
*** |